Witch’s Brew Punch

Name: Witch’s Brew Punch
Prep time: 10 min
Total time: 10 min
Cuisine: American
Ingredients: 2 liters grape soda, chilled; 52 ounces lemonade, chilled; 1 quart club soda, optional and chilled; 1 quart rainbow sherbet; Sprinkles for garnish

Author: Clara Hastings

Published: October 16, 2025

Print Recipe

Introduction to Witch’s Brew Punch

Come on in, home cooks! Because now is the time with the leaves turning, the air getting chilly for some spooky fun. My Witch’s Brew Punch is just what you need to have a very sweet and very festive Halloween celebration this year that pretty much makes me so in love. I mean, who wouldn’t glow from a beverage that is as bright as this one and tastes so delightful? And it only takes 10 minutes to make! Seriously, no matter how busy you are or what kind of great-acting mom you are planning a fun family night, this will add that pinch of magic to the celebration.

Why You’ll Love This Witch’s Brew Punch

This Witch’s Brew Punch is a game changer for busy moms and professionals like us! Not only is it quick to prepare—taking just 10 minutes—but it’s also fantastically delicious. Imagine the conversations it sparks at your gatherings! The sweet, fizzy mix of grape soda and lemonade, topped with creamy rainbow sherbet, creates a magical drink everyone will enjoy. Trust me, your guests will be spellbound!

Ingredients for Witch’s Brew Punch

Gathering the ingredients for my Witch’s Brew Punch is as fun as making it! Let’s dive into what you’ll need:

Grape soda: This bubbly base adds a sweet flavor and deep purple hue, making it perfect for setting the Halloween mood.
Lemonade: Adding a bright, tart twist, the lemonade balances the sweetness of the soda, creating a refreshing punch.
Club soda (optional): For those who love a bit of fizz, the club soda can enhance the bubbly delight without altering the flavor too much.
Rainbow sherbet: The real star! This scoopable wonder not only adds creaminess but also a delightful mix of fruity flavors and colors that kids (and adults) will adore.
Sprinkles: A fun touch that adds a burst of color to every cup! Feel free to go wild with Halloween-themed sprinkles if you have them on hand.

Don’t worry about measuring everything out just yet; the exact quantities can be found at the end of the article, making it easy for you to print. Enjoy the vibrant and delicious combination that’s sure to become a favorite in your home!

How to Make Witch’s Brew Punch

Making Witch’s Brew Punch is an easy and delightful experience that can be enjoyed by anyone—even the busiest of us! Follow these simple steps to create a refreshing and festive drink that will enchant your Halloween party guests.

Step 1: Combine the Base Ingredients

Begin by grabbing your favorite punch bowl—this is where the magic happens! Pour in the chilled grape soda and lemonade, stirring gently to blend them together.

If you want extra fizz, feel free to add the club soda at this point. Just remember to mix with a light hand to keep those lovely bubbles intact! The refreshing base of this punch is a vibrant mix of sweet and tart flavors that’s perfect for chasing away the autumn chill.

Step 2: Add the Rainbow Sherbet

Now comes the fun part! Take your quart of rainbow sherbet and scoop generous dollops to float on top of the punch. This not only adds a delightful creaminess but also a burst of color to your spooky concoction.

Consider layering it as you scoop—each spoonful of sherbet adds a swirl of fruity flavor. You’ll want to see those vibrant colors peeking through! It’s a visual treat that truly captures the spirit of Halloween.

Step 3: Serve and Enjoy

With everything combined, it’s time to serve this enchanting brew! Use a ladle to scoop the punch into cups, allowing a bit of the sherbet to float atop each serving. If you’re feeling extra festive, garnish with sprinkles for added flair!

Serve with excitement, and watch as your guests delight in this magical potion! You can even set up a fun drink station with spooky-themed cups or ice cubes hiding gummy worms for an added surprise. Beware—the fun might just be contagious!

Tips for Success

Chill all liquids beforehand to keep your punch refreshing.
Use a clear punch bowl to showcase the vibrant layers of color.
For a sweeter punch, adjust the lemonade according to taste.
Don’t skimp on the sherbet; it’s the star ingredient!
Create a festive atmosphere with fun cups and Halloween decorations.

Equipment Needed

Punch bowl: A classic choice, but a large mixing bowl works too.
Ladle: Perfect for serving, but a large measuring cup is a great alternative.
Scooper or spoon: To scoop out the rainbow sherbet—any large spoon will do!
Cups: Fun, festive cups make the punch even more enjoyable and can be store-bought or DIY.

Variations of Witch’s Brew Punch

Fruity Twist: Swap grape soda for cranberry or orange soda for a different fruity flavor profile!
Diet-Friendly: Choose diet versions of sodas for a lower-calorie option that doesn’t compromise on fun.
Non-Alcoholic Spike: Infuse with ginger ale or sparkling water for added zest and fizz!
Seasonal Flavors: Incorporate pumpkin spice or fall fruit purees for a cozy autumn flavor.
Colorful Layers: Alternate layers of different sorbets like mango or raspberry for a stunning visual effect!

Serving Suggestions for Witch’s Brew Punch

Spooky Snacks: Pair with Halloween-themed treats like ghost-shaped cookies or monster cupcakes for a festive spread.
Complementary Beverages: Serve alongside apple cider or a non-alcoholic spooky cocktail to offer guests options.
Presentation: Use dry ice for a mysterious fog effect—just be cautious about serving!

FAQs about Witch’s Brew Punch

Can I make Witch’s Brew Punch ahead of time?

Absolutely! You can mix the grape soda and lemonade a few hours in advance. Just add the club soda and sherbet right before serving to keep everything bubbly and fresh.

Can I customize the flavors in my Witch’s Brew Punch?

Of course! Feel free to swap out the grape soda for other fruity sodas like cran-apple or even tropical flavors. It’s all about what delights your taste buds!

Is this punch suitable for children?

Yes! Witch’s Brew Punch is a fun, non-alcoholic drink that kids will love. You can even add gummy worms or creepy ice cubes for a spooky twist.

How can I adjust the sweetness of the punch?

If you find it too sweet, consider using less lemonade or opting for a sugar-free soda. This way, you control the sugar levels while still enjoying a spooky drink!

What if I have leftovers?

If you have some punch left, store it in the fridge without the sherbet. Re-add the sherbet for any future gatherings, and it will still taste magical!

Final Thoughts

Creating Witch’s Brew Punch is not just about mixing ingredients; it’s about conjuring delightful moments with family and friends. The vibrant colors and refreshing flavors add an extra sprinkle of joy to any spooky gathering. Every ladle full brings giggles, smiles, and unforgettable memories, especially with kids involved. Trust me, this punch is sure to work its magic! As the punch bowl empties, you’ll cherish the laughter and connection it inspires. So, gather your loved ones, whip up this enchanting brew, and let the good times flow. Cheers to magical moments in every cup!